Dominic Ambrose Blogblot

of words: narrative, film and non-fiction

Marco Mengoni, Malika and Noemi the real winners at Sanremo 2010

Never mind which teenage heartthrob from the reality show circuit won the actual physical prizes, and don’t give any more attention to the faux victims, Pupo and the Prince – the standout performances at the 2010 Sanremo Festival were from Marco Mengoni, Malika Ayane, Noemi, Nina Zilli and Irene Grandi.

However, an unexpected and strange dynamic occurred in both the main and the secondary category with acts that appealed mainly to teenaged girls doing surprisingly well. (X Factor and Amici are the reality tv shows roughly equivalent to “American Idol” or “Star Academy,” etc. in other countries.)

When the three finalists for the main category of “Grandi” were announced, they included the over-the-top and suspiciously monarchist “Italia, amore mio,” written and performed in part by none other than Emanuele Filiberto of Savoia, the theoretical crown prince of Italy. This song caused endless discussion but a far more important issue was something else: the potentially disruptive fact that the festival was in danger of turning into a subsidiary of X Factor and Amici.

Marco Mengoni

The other two finalists were veterans of those other shows. One of them was Marco Mengoni with his excellent performance and innovative song. The other was from the absolute other end of the range of quality, a mediocre song with inane lyrics performed with bare technique by a young man clearly in over his head. There were three or four other excellent performances in the competition on a par with Mengoni’s, and it surprised everyone that singers like Malika Ayane and Noemi and Irene Grandi had been excluded. But the real surprise was still to come, when that other singer, an alumnus of Amici,  Valerio Scanu, won the top prize. The only reasonable explanation was that the internet campaign in his favor by his teenaged Amici following had been far more successful than anyone could have anticipated.

Similarly, in the “New Generation” category, the X Factor advantage was almost certainly a boost to help push Tony Maiello past Nina Zilli and the other contestants. In his case, however, one could argue that the doe-faced winner gave a credible performance with a good song. His victory did not cause controversy when it was announced on Friday evening, but then it unfortunately seemed to lose credibility when Scanu’s victory was announced on Saturday. What had begun as a revitalized festival had turned into a parody of itself, and the unusually vociferous dismay of the shouting audience in the theater and the protests of the orchestra musicians (who took to crumpling their sheet music and throwing it onto the stage) gave ample expression to the disappointment. The protests of the audience were probably, at least in part, due to the presence in the top three of the kitschy patriotic song presented by Pupo, Emanuele and the tenor Luca Canonici. But as the two drama queens, Pupo and the Prince, continued to cast themselves as the focus of all this controversy, they managed to obscure the real issue: the protests of the orchestra were almost certainly provoked by the exclusion of the best singers from the finalists.

Some Highlights: Unfortunately, the You Tube videos of these performances have been blocked by la RAI. 😦

 

Malika Ayane

Malika Ayane: She did well in last year’s contest, with her song “Come foglie,” but her return this year with “Ricomincio da qui” really proved her great ability and classic style. She held a certain appeal for being the most traditionally chic of the female contestants, but that doesn’t take anything away from her beautiful performance, which might remind some listeners of Ornella Vanoni.

Marco Mengoni: After his performance on the first evening, it is said that he received calls of congratulations from Mina and Adriano Celentano, both legends of Italian music. The call from Mina is particularly understandable, given that Marco’s style seems to be a re-interpretation of some of Mina’s stylistic trademarks. Yes, he is also a veteran of X Factor: he won, in fact. But he didn’t need (and apparently didn’t get much of) a boost from the starstruck teenage girls who seemed to prefer the non-threatening boyishness of other candidates.

Noemi at Sanremo

Of the other performances, Noemi (another X Factor veteran) and Irene Grandi were excellent, with powerful interpretations of quality songs.

Nino D’Angelo and Maria Nazionale sang “Yammo Ya,” in Neapolitan dialect. The song was good and was the opportunity for discussion about the role of dialect at Sanremo. Unfortunately, there isn’t much. It is difficult to imagine Lombards voted for something in Neapolitan dialect or Calabrians voting for something in Friulano. The song was out on the first night, and the debate was not advanced much by D’Angelo’s unpleasant attitude.

Povia tried to repeat his success in stirring controversy (last year he presented the abysmal song “Luca era gay” about a gay man that is “cured” of homosexuality by a beautiful woman). This year he has presented a song about a woman named Eulana Englaro, who had been in a coma for twenty years, and whose family decided to turn off life support. Fortunately, the public seems to be getting tired of his self-importance, and the song, though fairly good, did not get very far.

Another minor controversy was Simone Cristicchi’s song about Carla Bruni, “Meno Male.”

And then, of course, the brouhaha surrounding “Italia, Amore Mio.” It was milked to death by Pupo all week long, as he appeared on talk shows playing the victim. In a further effort to provoke antipathy, the trio appeared with Marcello Lippi, the manager of the National Soccer Team, who made a speech in support of the song, completely disregarding the rules of the competition. Less said about this tempest in a teapot, the better.

Tuto Cotugno participated, but he only succeeded in demonstrating that his voice no longer has the flexibility that it once had. He ended up shouting his lyrics unpleasantly. The song was an old fashioned trifle, very “sanremese,” and was eliminated as quickly as possible.

This being the sixtieth edition of the Song Contest, the third night (the contest runs over a period of five evening performances) luminaries from the world of Italian popular music were invited to present their own interpretations of classic Sanremo songs of the past. Carmen Consoli gave a truly inspired performance of the Nila Pizzi classic from the very first Sanremo festival in 1951, “Grazie dei Fior’. The Rai block on these You Tube videos is especially deleterious in this case: where else will people be able to hear or see this great performance?

In the “New Generation” category, Nina Zilli presented a song that provided a great showpiece for her beautiful Mediterranean jazz vocal style, also recalling Mina in some ways.

The Sanremo CD

Advertisements

February 21, 2010 - Posted by | music, performances | , , , , , , , ,

3 Comments »

  1. I heartily agree with all the above. Pupo and the Prince were a huge disappointment, unbelievable to me that the public would vote for them! Malika is my favourite. Her performance outshone everyone and the song is hauntingly beautiful. Brava Malika! Marco Mengoni is my second best.
    Also to mention here, I hope they bring back the two presenters of last year. They made the show very entertaining although I have to admit that Clerici did a decent job this year.

    Comment by Alba | February 23, 2010 | Reply

    • Thanks for the comment, Alba. Yes, Paolo Bonolis did a good job last year, but I must admit I liked the more streamlined style of this year’s presentation. I think Antonella Clerici did really well.

      Comment by dominicambrose | February 23, 2010 | Reply

  2. Rai uno is milking all this “controversy” for every advertising penny it can. As I type, people are still shouting over one another to express their tired opinions. But that such a silly song as Italia Mio Amore should even be considered, given the political corruption in this country, Berlusconi’s ownership of Rai, etc. Yikes! On the other hand, I do think Scanu has a nice enough voice, but not when he is singing at the bottom of his range, as he did at Sanremo. Thanks for the English language coverage.

    Comment by John | March 2, 2010 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: